Janice R. Andrews
In a smug appearance on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau shared his thoughts on why he believes Canada surpasses the United States in key areas. During his Tuesday night appearance, Trudeau took jabs at the U.S., highlighting issues such as the country’s approach to diversity, tariffs on Canadian lumber, and the absence of universal healthcare. His remarks, delivered with a sense of superiority, painted Canada as more progressive and inclusive than its southern neighbor.
Colbert kicked off the conversation with a lighthearted comment about Canada’s Hollywood stars, Ryan Gosling and Ryan Reynolds, before inviting Trudeau to share what makes Canada unique. Trudeau began by praising the country’s stunning natural beauty but quickly shifted to its diverse population, which he said celebrates differences rather than conforming to a single national identity as Americans tend to do.
“We try to celebrate differences,” Trudeau said, contrasting Canada’s mosaic of cultures with the U.S. melting pot. He shared an anecdote about the Polish prime minister, who was impressed that members of Canada’s Polish community continue to speak Polish generations after immigrating. Trudeau’s subtle critique implied that Americans lose more of their cultural identity in the process of assimilation.
Colbert chimed in, acknowledging the often-cited distinction between the two countries: “I’ve heard that America is a melting pot, whilst Canada sees itself as a mosaic.” This metaphor has long been used to contrast Canada’s emphasis on multiculturalism with the U.S.’s model of blending cultures into a more uniform national identity.
Trudeau’s smug tone didn’t stop at cultural comparisons. He touched on economic disputes between the two nations, pointing out that Americans pay too much for Canadian lumber due to tariffs. “You guys are paying too much for your lumber because you have tariffs on them, and that doesn’t make any sense,” Trudeau remarked, suggesting that the U.S. needs to reevaluate its trade policies.
One of the most biting moments came when Colbert brought up the fact that many Americans travel to Canada to access cheaper prescription drugs. Trudeau’s response, a nod to Canada’s healthcare system, drew applause from the audience. “We’re happy to help you out,” he quipped, “but it would be a lot easier if you guys had universal healthcare.” His comment underscored the stark difference between the two countries’ healthcare systems, with Canada’s single-payer model often held up as a point of national pride compared to the U.S.’s privatized system.
The conversation also veered into lighter territory, with Colbert asking about Canada’s coins, many of which feature the British monarch. With Queen Elizabeth II having recently passed, Colbert joked about whether Canadians would need “King money” now that Charles III is on the throne. Trudeau confirmed that new currency featuring King Charles would be phased in over time, but there was no rush to do so.
Despite Trudeau’s jabs at the U.S., his position at home remains precarious. The prime minister returned to Canada the next day and survived a vote of confidence in Parliament. His minority Liberal government won the vote 211-120 after a motion by the opposition Conservative Party was defeated. The vote followed a tumultuous period for Trudeau, whose popularity has slumped amid a housing crisis and rising inflation. His political standing weakened further when the New Democratic Party, which had been supporting his government, withdrew its backing earlier this month.
Although Trudeau has faced increasing challenges at home, his appearance on Colbert seemed aimed at shoring up his image internationally. While some Americans may have taken offense at his tone, Trudeau’s remarks reflect a longstanding Canadian narrative that contrasts their country’s inclusivity and progressive policies with America’s more divisive political climate.
As the 2025 election looms, Trudeau’s ability to navigate domestic dissatisfaction while maintaining Canada’s global reputation will likely determine whether he can extend his Liberal Party’s nearly decade-long hold on power. For now, however, his comments on Colbert may resonate with those who share his belief that Canada offers a better alternative to its southern neighbor.
